Rabbi Benny Berlin

When your in-law is Lavan, build a boundary

Posted

Every rabbi knows the phone call. It usually comes right after a holiday. A husband or wife, voice tight, asks some version of the same question: “Rabbi, my parent is impossible. My in-laws are making our lives miserable. What does the Torah actually want from me?”

The Torah has a long answer, and its name is Lavan.

It is hard to find a worse father-in-law anywhere in Tanakh. Yaakov loved Rachel so deeply that seven years of work seemed like only a few days. Then, on his wedding night, Lavan switched his daughters. When Yaakov confronted him, Lavan brushed it off: “Lo yei’aseh chen bimkomeinu (That is simply not how we do things around here).”

Over 20 years, Lavan changed Yaakov’s wages 10 times. And when they finally faced off, he delivered one of the most chilling lines in the Torah: “Habanos benosai vehabanim banai vehatzon tzoni (The daughters are my daughters, the children are my children, the sheep are my sheep).” Everything you see is mine.

Daughters, grandchildren, livestock. To Lavan, they were all possessions. His daughters knew it: “Halo nochriyos nechshavnu lo (Are we not considered strangers to him?)”

So how do we honor a parent or in-law like Lavan without letting them control our marriages and our homes?

People in difficult family relationships often feel trapped between two extremes. They either tolerate everything to keep the peace or distance themselves so completely that the relationship collapses. Yaakov’s story holds elements of both.

• • •

For 20 years, Yaakov endured Lavan’s schemes through scorching days and freezing nights. Then he left in secret. As the Torah states, “Vayignov Yaakov es lev Lavan ha’Arami al bli higid lo ki vore’ach hu (Yaakov deceived Lavan the Aramean by not telling him that he was fleeing).” But neither his silent endurance nor his secret departure ended the conflict. Lavan pursued him for seven days and overtook him in the mountains of Gilad.

The family therapist Murray Bowen called the healthier alternative “differentiation.” It means remaining emotionally connected to another person without surrendering the ability to think, decide and act independently. We can love someone without obeying every demand.

At Gilad, Yaakov finds that path: “Vayichar l’Yaakov vayarev b’Lavan (Yaakov became angry and quarreled with Lavan).” With his back to the wall, he speaks with a force we have not heard before, naming the heat of the day, the frost of the night and the injustice he endured.

Then Yaakov and Lavan gather stones and build a monument called Gal-ed, sealing a covenant that neither will cross it to harm the other. A pile of stones marking a line.

Rabbi Larry Rothwachs recently explained on the Orthodox Conundrum podcast that a boundary is not a demand that someone else change. It is a decision about how we ourselves will respond. He offered a simple illustration. “Please don’t criticize my wife” is a request. “If my wife is criticized, I will end the conversation” is a boundary.

• • •

Peace does not always require agreement. Sometimes it requires recognizing where one person’s authority ends and another person’s life begins.

The very next morning tells the rest of the story: “Vayashkem Lavan baboker vayenashek levanav velivnosav vayevarech es’hem (Lavan rose early, kissed his grandchildren and his daughters, and blessed them).”

The relationship did not end. It changed shape.

Halacha strikes the same balance. We must honor our parents, and our in-laws too, but honor is not surrender. The Rema rules that a son need not obey a parent who objects to the woman he wishes to marry. We can preserve a parent’s dignity while protecting the integrity of our own homes. Some relationships require real distance for safety, but many survive precisely because healthy limits are set.

Lavan said, “Everything you see is mine.” Yaakov answered with a pile of stones. Sometimes the holiest thing we can build in a hard family is not a bridge. It is a boundary that lets the bridge survive.

Rabbi Benny Berlin is spiritual leader of BACH in Long Beach. www.bachlongbeach.com.