Carin Smilk

The day eaters starved the haters in Philly?

Posted

Two days after a boycott against six Jewish- and Israeli-owned restaurants in Philadelphia, and one day after arriving back from a week in Israel, I found myself pounding the pavement at night, walking from eatery to eatery in Center City, looking for scraps.

Not leftovers in the literal sense of the word. But when the party is over, some detritus tends to remain.

So do anger, rancor, melancholy, dread and introspection — feelings that go with being targeted on the streets.

That’s what happened to members of the local Jewish community on Nov. 8, one day before the 88th anniversary of the infamous Kristallnacht, “Night of the Broken Glass.”

On Nov. 9-10, 1938, Nazi stormtroopers and party members burned and destroyed as many as 1,400 synagogues and prayer rooms in Germany and Austria; looted and vandalized 7,500 Jewish-owned businesses; smashed other Jewish institutions, organizations and even homes; and murdered nearly 100 people. Some 30,000 Jewish men were arrested and sent to concentration camps, including Dachau, Buchenwald and Sachsenhausen.

That is not what occurred in Philly on Sunday. It didn’t because this is America in 2026, not Europe in the late 1930s. A world war is not on the immediate horizon.

Still, it came less than a week after a volatile midterm election that had Israel and the Jews on the ballot, and that saw the election of the first Muslim senator in the United States, a man who has repeatedly put the State of Israel in the crosshairs.

And it didn’t occur because, as has been widely reported, as many as 2,000 people didn’t let it. The Jewish and pro-Israel community and its supporters came out in full force to patronize six targeted eateries: Huda, K’Far Café, Mac Mart, Dizengoff, Goldie and Schlesinger’s, each of which is Jewish- or Israeli-owned. (Goldie, a falafel restaurant, is kosher.)

It was noticeable that the list didn’t include Zahav.

• • •

This swanky Michael Solomonov establishment, which opened in 2008, won the James Beard Award for Outstanding Restaurant in 2019 and has consistently ranked among Philadelphia’s top restaurants. Solomonov, an Israeli-American chef, also won the James Beard Award for Outstanding Chef in 2017. Ask anyone in town, and they’ll acknowledge that getting a reservation there requires persistence, timing and a little mazal.

Zahav sits in Society Hill, near the waterfront and a swath of cobblestone streets. Perhaps the bikers thought it too far or too slippery to include in their BDS aspirations.

The so-called “Boycott Ride” was organized by Philly Bike On Your Left in collaboration with Boycott CookNSolo and Philly Solidarity Calendar. A flier promoting the antisemitic effort stated: “No business for Zionists” and “These Zionist establishments must go.”

Notice of its ill intentions made it all the way to Israel, where I — a third-generation Philadelphian — got wind of the impending boycott while on a press trip sponsored by the Or Ofir Foundation and the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The program was titled “Standing Against Antisemitism: Voices, Stories and Action.”

The irony didn’t escape me.

So after a day of working and fighting jet lag, in the waning hours of what I could only imagine was massive destruction and despair nearly 90 years ago this very night, I enticed my husband and two of my sons to go out to eat (not a hard sell).

We headed to Dizengoff, also owned and operated by Solomonov and chef/partner Steve Cook through their restaurant group, CookNSolo Restaurants. Three of the targeted restaurants were already closed for the day; this one had the most room and later hours, and we’d never been there before.

• • •

We got a table immediately, which one server noted was unusual. Normally there’s a wait, he said, even on weekdays. On Sunday, the line formed “before the place even opened,” he told us.

As we looked over the menu, two men sitting next to us were deep in conversation. One asked the other if he had heard of a book called “Start-up Nation.” He described its contents, telling his fellow diner about desalination, drip irrigation and Israeli defense.

Multiple works share this title; I wasn’t sure which one they were referencing. All I knew (and appreciated, especially that night) was that they were stewing — and chewing — over developments in the Middle East.

A different server said it was “ridiculously busy” on Sunday and that the restaurant “came out on top,” both socially and financially.

That was confirmed earlier in the day by Marti Lieberman, owner of another of the targeted places, Mac Mart.

Lieberman said the shop typically serves 30 to 50 meals a day, being a smaller food model in a standalone kiosk. It has been in its current location for only about a year, and “we’re still in that education phase,” she said.

“If I get 50 people a day, I’m happy. I had more than four times that on Sunday,” she said. “We were overwhelmed by the support.”

In fact, she sold so much food that she had to close the next day, Monday, to restock.

“It backfired — it backfired 100%,” she said of the boycotters. “It’s mind-blowing that this 105-square-foot mac-and-cheese place, smaller than a food truck, was brought into this. They found us and made assumptions.”

But at the end of the day, said the 37-year-old, “it helped my business. People donated money — it started pouring in — and we want to pay it forward. We are going to donate it to the hungry, to food efforts, foundations.”

• • •

Back at Dizengoff, with the baba ganoush and labneh appetizers polished off, every speck of tahini ketchup scraped up by crispy fries, the sabich sandwich boxed to go home and four forks surrounding an olive-oil cake with a dollop of vanilla cream and a circle of apple butter, I turned to the table behind us.

Nancy Bergen, David Kalkstein and his son, Seth Kalkstein, were finishing their meal. They had come to support the restaurant on Sunday but couldn’t get in. “The lines were around the corner,” said Bergen. Later, she learned that Dizengoff had run out of tomatoes and cucumbers, crucial ingredients for a classic Middle Eastern salad.

“The energy was through the roof,” she said. “Everybody was united against hatred of the Jewish people. It was such a bust for the boycotters.”

She mentioned that a similar event was planned and then cancelled for Nov. 15 — a “ride of return” (a play on the Palestinian demand for a “right of return” to lands that became part of modern-day Israel in May 1948), also timed to a “Ride for Israel” with a more positive message: that antisemitism and hatred have no place in Philly or anywhere else.

The elder Kalkstein, who’s originally from Tel Aviv, said, “They want to drive us out. That really got me.” He feels that antisemitism has never left — “that it’s always been there” and “that it rears its head every so often.”

His wife said the boycotters claim that their efforts are anti-Zionist, not anti-Jewish. She knows better, adding that “we talk about this all the time. Every day, we are upset.”

Seth Kalkstein, a software engineer, said he has lost most of his non-Jewish friends over this in the past few years: “They want to globalize the intifada.”

He amended that and said he had a few left, though he didn’t sound convinced. When I noticed the crutches next to his chair, he responded: “Yep. I went on Sunday, crutches and all.”

As we left, Bergen suggested that we come back and “try the fish.”

Lieberman, at Mac Mart, which advertises “cheesey macs, snax & more local goodies to go,” was more optimistic.

She spent 14 years in business in a different part of the city, Rittenhouse Square, where the crowd initially gathered on Sunday — anti-Israel protesters and pro-Israel supporters, with police trying to maintain order. Groups had formed days earlier from synagogues, community centers, neighborhoods and schools in the heavily Jewish suburbs and even exurbs to send a message.

She didn’t seem shaken. She seemed strengthened. “Good will always prevail,” she said. “This is living proof.”

Carin M. Smilk is managing editor of the US bureau at JNS.