The State Department Almost Scuttled U.S. Recognition Of Israel

When Israel’s Chief Rabbi, Isaac Herzog, visited the White House after Israel’s independence was declared, he told Truman, “G-d put you in your mother’s womb so that you would be the instrument to bring the rebirth of Israel after 2000 years.”

The birth of Israel was a true miracle that went way beyond the tiny Jewish State’s defeat of the stronger Arab League armies. Harry Truman ignored a secretary of state who was more popular than he was to make sure the U.S. was the first country to recognize the nascent Jewish state.

“What I am trying to do is make the whole world safe for Jews,” Harry Truman wrote as he agonized over his decision to recognize a Jewish state in Palestine.

Secretary of State George Marshall (Time’s 1947 Man of the Year) was just as opposed to the creation of Israel as Truman was for it.

Clark M. Clifford, Special Counsel to President Truman at the time, remembered the internal U.S. fight regarding the recognition of the Jewish State---the final discussion in the oval office. The meeting turned out to be an angry battle with Clifford and the President on one side, Marshall and Undersecretary of State Robert Lovett on the other.

The argument used many of the same memes used today.

Lovett first argued that Truman was supporting Israel solely for political gain and he warned the president that the move would lose more votes than it would garner. When that didn’t work, Lovett tried another approach, the “red” scare (because you know all of those Jews are commies). As Clifford recalls:

“’Mr. President, to recognize the Jewish state prematurely would be buying a pig in a poke,’ Lovett continued. ‘How do we know what kind of Jewish state will be set up? We have many reports from British and American intelligence agents that Soviets are sending Jews and commu¬nist agents into Palestine from the Black Sea area.’ Lovett read some of these intelligence reports to the group. I found them ridiculous, and no evidence ever turned up to support them; in fact, Jews were fleeing communism throughout Eastern Europe at that very moment.”

When Lovett was done speaking it was Marshall’s turn:

“With barely contained rage and more than a hint of self-righ¬teousness, he made the most remarkable threat I ever heard anyone make directly to a President: “If you follow Clifford’s advice and if I were to vote in the election, I would vote against you.”

Everyone in the room was stunned. Here was the indispensable symbol of continuity whom President Truman revered and needed, making a threat that, if it became public, could virtually seal the dissolution of the Truman Administration and send the Western Alliance, then in the process of creation, into disarray before it had been fully structured. Marshall’s statement fell short of an explicit threat to resign, but it came very close.”

General Marshall’s position was grossly unfair. Just like today, opponents of the Jewish State believed the sole reason for the President’s support was politics.

But Truman’s mind was made up; he was going to do the right thing. At 4 P.M. Friday, May 14, 1948, just before the start of Shabbos, David Ben-Gurion read a 979-word declaration of independence in front of a small audience at the Tel Aviv Art Museum. He finished in his usual terse manner. “The State of Israel is established! The meeting is ended.” At midnight, British rule over Palestine lapsed; 11 minutes later White House spokesman Charlie Ross announced U.S. recognition.

In 1961, long after he was out of office, Truman met with Israeli PM David Ben-Gurion in NY. Ben-Gurion said this about the meeting:

“At our last meeting, after a very interesting talk, just before [the President] left me--it was in a New York hotel suite--I told him that as a foreigner I could not judge what would be his place in American history; but his helpfulness to us, his constant sympathy with our aims in Israel, his courageous decision to recognize our new state so quickly and his steadfast support since then had given him an immor¬tal place in Jewish history. As I said that, tears suddenly sprang to his eyes. And his eyes were still wet when he bade me goodbye. I had rarely seen anyone so moved. I tried to hold him for a few minutes until he had become more composed, for I recalled that the hotel corridors were full of waiting journalists and photographers. He left. A little while later, I, too, had to go out and a correspondent came to me to ask, “Why was President Truman in tears when he left you?”

I believe that I know. These were the tears of a man who had been subjected to calumny and vilification, who had persisted against powerful forces within his own Administration determined to defeat him. These were the tears of a man who had fought ably and honorably for a humani¬tarian goal to which he was deeply committed. These were tears of thanksgiving that his God had seen fit to bless his labors with success.”

How times have changed. In 1948 our President used a moral compass to decide foreign policy. Truman was a President who judged not whether things would make us popular in Europe and the Arab world, but whether it was the right thing for the U.S. to do for our future and the future of the world. Truman saw the Presidency as the leadership position of the entire world.

Our President today sees the U.S. as nothing special, not a leader but one of many countries on the planet. He has described his strategy as “leading from behind.” Doing the right thing is not as important as finding favor among those countries that hate us because of what we represent. And if that means we have to throw our historical allies under the bus, so be it.

The morality behind Truman’s direction helped to make America strong. Like most of his agenda, Obama’s “let’s be friends with the people who hate us,” will only serve to drive this country towards mediocrity and put our children and grandchildren in danger.

Jeff Dunetz is the Editor/Publisher of the political blog “The Lid” (www.jeffdunetz.com). Jeff contributes to some of the largest political sites on the internet including American Thinker, Big Government, Big Journalism, NewsReal and Pajama’s Media, and has been a guest on national radio shows including G. Gordon Liddy, Tammy Bruce and Glenn Beck. Jeff lives in Long Island.