Three years after Oct. 7, American Jews are in a war they are fighting without a plan, and they are losing, veteran Jewish leader David Harris warned at Touro University on Monday.
“We are in a war without a war cabinet, without a war plan, without a war mindset, and without a war leadership,” Harris said. “How much longer will it take?”
But he insisted that American Jews would not cower. “We are not going to be the new generation of Marrano Jews,” he said. “We are proud Jews. We are strong Jews, and we are Jews without trembling knees.”
Harris, who was CEO of the American Jewish Committee from 1990 to 2022 and is now executive vice president of the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP), spoke Nov. 16 at Touro’s inaugural Symposium on Antisemitism, held at the university’s 3 Times Square campus in Manhattan. He used the address to lay out a 10-point plan for a community that, he said, has no strategy at all.
He built his remarks around the Hebrew word konseptzia (conception), the term Israelis use for the assumption, held until Oct. 6, 2023, that Hamas would not attack. Israel, then bitterly split over judicial reform, adopted a new konseptzia within days, taking the battle to the enemy on seven fronts as former rivals “fought together in shared purpose in the foxholes.”
“What is the American Jewish conception post October 7?” Harris asked. “If it exists, quite frankly, I, for one, am unaware.”
Until that day, Harris said, American Jews clung to the notion of American exceptionalism. Bad things might happen in France, “the country of Dreyfus and Vichy,” or in Spain or Ireland, “but not here.”
He recalled George Washington’s 1790 promise to Newport’s Jews of a government that “gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance.” “And we believed him,” Harris said. “Post October the seventh, we learned that, as blessed as we have been to live in this country, America is not immune.”
Had American Jewry organized D-Day, he joked, “the army would not have spoken to the navy. The navy would not have spoken to the Air Force …”
Unifying every American Jew is “a goal too far,” he said, but not the mainstream, the 75% to 85% who “know in their kishkes that they are proud to be Jews” and who are “not drawn into these endless Talmudic debates about whether anti-Zionism is or is not antisemitism when it so obviously is.”
Quoting Yad Vashem’s finding that in the 1930s “there was no one American Jewish community,” he asked, “Sound familiar?”
Harris saved his sharpest words for Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, who is Jewish. Speaking Aug. 30 at a Michigan Democratic Party Jewish Caucus event, Nessel invoked Queen Esther and said Jews might need to “sacrifice the comfort, safety, and security, and even the very future of our own people in exchange for the opportunity to save the rest of humanity.”
“Did you hear that quote?” Harris asked. “That’s one konseptzia. Let us become the sacrificial lambs for humanity.”
He likened her words to a 1934 statement by the Association of National German Jews, quoted, he said, in the New York Times “when it was still the New York Times,” that its members had always placed the good of the German people “above our own good.” Then he offered his own konseptzia.
Harris cited exit polls showing that half or more of Michigan Jews voted for Abdul El-Sayed, who won the state’s US Senate seat Nov. 3 and whom Harris called “so unabashedly, openly opposed to the very existence of the state of Israel.” He faulted El-Sayed’s response to the March attack on Temple Israel in West Bloomfield: “hurt people hurt people.” El-Sayed later apologized for the remark.
“What’s gone wrong?” he asked, noting that a third of New York City Jews, “we’re told,” backed a mayor who “certainly did not have the best interests of the Jewish community” at heart, a reference to Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
Of Jewish advocacy organizations, he said, “Some have still not gotten the memo.” He praised the Brandeis Center, the National Jewish Advocacy Center and ISGAP, and pointed to the Trump administration’s terrorist designations of Muslim Brotherhood chapters. “That’s outcome,” he said.
“Once upon a time, there were consequences for antisemitism,” Harris said. “You couldn’t for long be a member of the United States Congress. … It’s time to restore the consequences.”
A lifelong nonpartisan, Harris quipped that his mother died “still not knowing how her son voted. I couldn’t trust her with a hairdresser.” His message to both parties: “Don’t ever take the Jewish vote for granted again.”
His final point borrowed Israeli slang. “We need to stop being frayers. A frayer is a sucker,” he said. Institutions that once considered Jewish money “tainted” now court it, and “just about every hospital, and museum, and concert hall in this country has a Jewish connection, and G-d bless the donors.”
Citing remarks earlier in the day by New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin about the Metropolitan Museum of Art, which in August canceled an exhibit honoring designer John Galliano over his antisemitic remarks, Harris said Jewish givers must get smarter, starting with institutions that serve their own young people.
Harris said the community “can’t continue to do things as we’ve done them until today, and expect different results.”
“Ladies and gentlemen, from where I sit, we are losing. We are losing,” he said. “The good news is it may only be the fourth inning. The game has many more innings to go.”
But unless American Jews change, “recognize the moment” and draw on the resources within the community “and among friends and potential friends,” he warned, “I fear we’ll have more conferences and fewer and fewer bits of good news.”