antisemitism symposium

Saying grace proudly, then hiding Jewish stars

Posted

When Malka Fleischmann arrived at college, she couldn’t make her non-Jewish classmates understand that Hillel wasn’t just another extracurricular activity for her. It was, she said, “the oxygen.”

Then, near the end of her first semester, she sat down at an interfaith dinner beside a Catholic student whose upbringing mirrored her own: religious day school, religious summer camp, the primacy of family and community, expectations of modesty and of literacy in sacred texts.

When it came time to say grace after meals, Fleischmann didn’t excuse herself or pretend to take a phone call. She said it right there at the table, and her new friend waited, quiet and respectful, until she finished.

“For me, that was extraordinary,” Fleischmann, director of Touro University’s Antisemitism Institute, told the university’s Symposium on Antisemitism on Monday. “I had never experienced such compassionate behavior for my Judaism and my religious practice outside of my own community.”

Moments like that, she said, taught her that her Judaism “could live and breathe without apology in the public square.” She sank deeper into her faith, carried her passion for cross-cultural understanding to divinity school, and in 2014 accepted an invitation from Touro President Dr. Alan Kadish to launch interfaith programming at Touro’s graduate schools.

After four years she moved on. Now she is back, she said, “proudly, but not quite as dewy-eyed as I once was.”

“The college campus, the world that made my world expand beyond measure, the place for which my passion runs deepest,” she said, “that place is becoming unrecognizable.”

Three years ago, at her own alma mater, a student protester shouted at Jewish classmates to go back to Moscow, Brooklyn and Berlin. Fleischmann pictured her own college friends in that crowd: the founders of a Muslim-Jewish community service group, the leaders of the interfaith council, students honored for fostering constructive change on campus.

“That’s who wouldn’t be welcome,” she said. “That’s who isn’t welcome. The people who fight for democratic values.”

She cited findings from Stanford and Columbia, including a guest lecturer who questioned the six million figure of Jewish Holocaust victims.

“When I was a student, I proudly said grace after meals in full view of my classmates,” she said. “Today’s students are hiding their Jewish star necklaces, putting their Israeli flags under their beds.”

Still, she refuses to despair. “What has been taught can be untaught,” she said.

This past summer, the institute launched the Touro University Teaching Fellowship to Combat Campus Antisemitism, bringing nine professors of literature, law and history, including one from Slovakia, to build new courses on antisemitism to teach on their home campuses.

Fleischmann closed with a question a mentor once posed to her: Where were you when the Maccabees revolted, when Rome bore down, during the Dreyfus affair, when Soviet Jewry cried out for freedom? Where are you now, with Jewish students afraid on campus?

“The answer is, we are here,” she said. “Touro is here, and you are here with us.”