Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks z"tl

Leah’s unheard tears and the art of listening

Posted

We sometimes forget that the phrase Keriat Ha-Torah does not simply mean “reading the Torah.” In biblical Hebrew the verb likro means not “to read” but “to call.” The phrase mikra’ei kodesh, the festivals, literally means “holy convocations,” days on which the people were summoned together. In the historic gathering of those who had returned from Babylon, Ezra “read [the Torah] aloud from daybreak till noon … and all the people listened attentively.”

Keriat Ha-Torah therefore means not reading but proclaiming the Torah. The one who reads has the written word in front of him, but for the rest of the gathering it is an experience not of the eye but of the ear. Only with the spread of manuscripts, and then the invention of printing in the 15th century, did reading become a visual experience. We miss some of the most subtle effects of Torah if we think of it as the word seen rather than the word heard.

One difference between sound and sight has to do with time. We can see — but not hear — a sentence at a single glance. Halfway through a spoken sentence we can guess what will come next, but we cannot be sure until we hear the words. That is why jokes are funnier heard than read: Listening, we are kept in suspense. Reading, we can skip to the punchline.

To give one biblical example: When Joseph is in prison, he interprets the dream of Pharaoh’s butler: “Within three days Pharaoh will lift up your head and restore you to your position.” Emboldened, the baker tells his own dream. Joseph begins with the same words, “Within three days Pharaoh will lift up your head,” but then adds, “from the rest of you; he will hang you on a tree.” This is humor at its blackest — and it works only when heard. The Torah is written to be read aloud, and several of its literary devices depend on the power of the next word to confound our expectations.

• • •

One of the most striking examples occurs in Vayetzei, this week’s sedra. Jacob, in flight from Esau’s anger, comes to the house of Laban, meets his younger daughter Rachel and falls in love with her.

He works seven years for her hand, but on the wedding night Laban substitutes Leah. When Jacob protests, Laban pointedly replies, “It is not the done thing in our place to give the younger before the elder” (a reference, intended or otherwise, to Jacob’s own deception of his father). Laban agrees that for a further seven years’ labor Jacob may marry Rachel, after first completing Leah’s week of wedding celebration (an early example of a custom we still keep: sheva brachot).

We then read: “He also [gam] married Rachel, and he also [gam] loved Rachel…” (Bereishit 29:30)

The repeated word gam, “also,” leads us to believe that the two sisters are equal in Jacob’s eyes. The story of the deception has — or so we suppose — a happy ending after all. The sibling rivalry so pronounced in Bereishit (Cain and Abel, Isaac and Ishmael, Jacob and Esau) seems to be reaching a positive resolution.

The next words send our expectation crashing to the ground: “…more than Leah.” (Bereishit 29:30)

This is an ungrammatical construction. Either one loves X and also Y, or one loves X more than Y, but not both. The effect, like a sudden discord in the middle of a Mozart symphony, is strident and shocking.

The next verse contains an even sharper discord: “G-d saw that Leah was hated [senuah]…” (Bereishit 29:31)

This cannot be understood literally; the previous verse has just said that Leah was loved. Ramban and Radak read senuah as “[relatively] unloved.” Yet though the text is semantically strange, it is psychologically lucid. Leah knew that Jacob’s heart was elsewhere. She may have been loved, but she felt the lesser love as a rejection. The words “G-d saw” mean that G-d felt her humiliation. Laban’s deception had human consequences, and they were tragic.

• • •

Only now do we understand the significance of the Torah’s first mention of Leah: “Laban had two daughters; the elder was called Leah and the younger was called Rachel. Leah had weak [rakot] eyes, but Rachel was beautiful and lovely.” (Bereishit 29:16-17)

The word rakot could mean beautiful (Targum, Rashbam), weak (Ibn Ezra), or sensitive (Netziv). The ambiguity is deliberate. Only rarely does the Torah describe its characters physically, and always for a reason that will eventually be disclosed. The meaning here, as Rashi, Radak and various midrashic traditions explain, is “Leah was easily moved to tears.” She was thin-skinned, sensitive, attuned to nuance, easily hurt. She knew she was Jacob’s lesser love, and it caused her pain.

What follows is, on the face of it, a simple account of the birth of four children. Beneath the surface, these verses are as eloquent as any in the Torah:

When G-d saw that Leah was unloved, He opened her womb, but Rachel remained barren. Leah became pregnant and had a son. She named him Reuben, saying: “The L-rd has seen [ra’ah] my affliction. Now my husband will love me.” She became pregnant again and had a son. She said, “The L-rd has heard [shama] that I am unloved, so He has given me this son also,” and she named him Shimon. She became pregnant again and had a son and said, “Now that I have borne him three sons, my husband will become attached [lavah] to me.”

Therefore he named the child Levi. She became pregnant again and had a son. She said, “This time I will praise [odeh] the L-rd,” so she named him Judah. She then ceased having children. (Bereishit 29:31-35)

Read superficially, these verses are no more than a genealogy. Once our ear is attuned to Leah’s plight, what we hear is heartbreaking.

Leah is pleading for attention. Each of the names of her first three children is a cry to her husband — to see, to listen, to be attached, to love. Significantly, it is she, not Jacob, who names three of the children. (Rashi, following the midrash, says Levi was named by an angel. He has understood that a key fact about the four births is the absence of Jacob.)

Sadly, that absence carries through the years to come. Jacob’s relationship with Reuben, Shimon and Levi breaks down, and on his deathbed he rebukes them instead of blessing them. Yet from Levi will come Israel’s spiritual leaders, and from Judah its kings.

Nor does Jacob hear Rachel’s distress: “To Jacob she said, ‘Give me children! If not, let me die!’ Jacob grew angry with Rachel, and said, ‘Am I in place of G-d, who has kept you from having children’?” (Bereishit 30:1-2)

The Sages heard an echo of these words at the end of Bereishit, when Joseph comforts his frightened brothers: “Do not be afraid. Am I in the place of G-d?” The son uses his father’s words to opposite effect. Of Jacob’s reply to Rachel, the Sages said: “Said the Holy One, blessed be He [to Jacob]: ‘Is that the way to answer a woman in distress? By your life, your children will one day stand before her son’.”

• • •

What is going on in this intense and sometimes tragic drama? Jacob is unlike the other patriarchs. If the word that comes to mind in relation to Abraham is chessed, kindness, and to Isaac pachad, fear, the idea that characterizes Jacob is struggle.

Already in the womb he struggles with his brother. He competes with him for the birthright and the blessing. The defining scene in his life is his wrestling match at night with an unnamed adversary. Both his names — Jacob, “he who grasps by the heel,” and Israel, “he who struggles with G-d and man and prevails” — convey a sense of conflict. The gifts he has, he has fought for. The prophet Micah associated him with truth: “You give truth to Jacob, kindness to Abraham.” Truth rarely comes without a struggle and the pain of experience.

One truth Jacob must learn is about love. The word “love” appears once in the story of Abraham, twice in the life of Isaac, but seven times in the case of Jacob. Jacob loves more than any other figure in Bereishit.

Yet love not only unites; it can also divide. It did so in his childhood, when Isaac loved Esau and Rebecca loved Jacob. It did so again when he married two sisters. It did so a third time when he loved Rachel’s child Joseph more than his other sons. What Jacob learned — and what we learn, reading his story — is that love is not enough. We must also heed those who feel unloved. That requires the ability to listen: in Jacob’s case, to the unspoken tears of Leah, made explicit in the names she gave her sons.

I began by pointing out that the Torah is a text intended to be read aloud and listened to. It is the single greatest expression of faith in a G-d we cannot see, but only hear. Judaism is supremely a religion of the ear, unlike all other ancient civilizations, which were cultures of the eye. This is more than a metaphysical fact. It is a moral one as well. In Judaism the highest spiritual gift is the ability to listen — not only to the voice of G-d, but also to the cry of other people, the sigh of the poor, the weak, the lonely, the neglected and, yes, sometimes the un- or less-loved. That is one of the meanings of the great command Shema Yisrael, “Listen, O Israel.” Jacob’s other name, we recall, was Israel.

It is not that Jacob has a moral failing. It is rather that every virtue has a corresponding danger. Those who are courageous are often unaware of the fears of ordinary people. Those who, like Jacob, have an unusual capacity to love must fight against the danger of failing to honor the feelings of those they do not love with equal passion. The antidote is the ability to listen. That is what Jacob learns in the course of his life, and why he is the role model for the Jewish people, the nation commanded to listen.

How beautiful it is that this message is conveyed in passages whose meaning discloses itself only to those who listen to what is going on beneath the words: the unspoken cry, the implicit appeal, the unheard tears. Those who wish to listen to G-d must learn to listen to other people — to the kol demamah dakah, “the still, small voice,” of those who need our love.

Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks (1948-2020) was chief rabbi of the United Hebrew Congregations of the Commonwealth from 1991 to 2013.