Life, with woes, is what Mishkan Hashem chose
There is a famous philosophical framework articulated by Plato that divides reality into two distinct realms. In the perfect realm exists the true tree, the true chair, the absolute form of every concept. And then there is our world, which Plato considered merely a partial and imperfect reflection of that higher reality. Truth exists above, in the realm of perfect forms.
It is an idea the Torah quietly rejects in Parshas Vayakhel Pekudei.
The question begins with an obvious difficulty. The Torah is written in famously condensed language. Entire bodies of halacha are derived from a single extra letter or a seemingly redundant word. And yet here we encounter two full parshios that appear to repeat material we already know.
Parshas Terumah already recorded every detail of the Mishkan’s construction, down to the most precise specifications, as Hashem commanded Moshe. Why does the Torah spend two additional parshios repeating every plank, every curtain, every socket as Bnei Yisrael actually built it?
One sentence would have sufficed. Bnei Yisrael did everything exactly as Hashem commanded.
Why the repetition?
Many commentators note that the Torah describes not one Mishkan but two.
• • •
The Mishkan of Terumah exists first as a perfect divine vision. Flawless, ideal, a heavenly blueprint. And then there is the Mishkan of Vayakhel and Pekudei, constructed by human hands in the desert. By definition, it is imperfect. It is built by finite people attempting to translate a divine vision into the messy reality of the physical world.
These are two entirely different structures. And yet it is specifically the second Mishkan, the human one, the imperfect one, where Hashem chooses to place His presence.
This is the Torah’s profound inversion of Plato. The Gemara states that Hashem does not enter the Yerushalayim shel maalah (the heavenly Jerusalem) until He first enters the Yerushalayim shel matah (the earthly Jerusalem) (Taanit 5a). The divine presence chooses to dwell not in abstract perfection first but in the imperfect reality created by human hands.
And that truth has a human face.
A young couple from Krakow had been deeply in love before the Holocaust. The Nazi deportations separated them, and each believed the other had been killed. On the day of liberation, the young man spotted his kallah across the fence. They entered an abandoned home, and she caught a glimpse of herself in a broken mirror.
She was horrified. Her hair had been shaved. Her body was gaunt and bruised. She looked nothing like the young woman he had once known.
She turned to him and said, how can you possibly love me looking like this?
And he answered, you have never been more beautiful to me than you are right now.
He was not seeing the external. He was seeing a human being who had endured unimaginable darkness and still chose to live, to love, to walk forward. That shaken but unbroken will to continue, that was the beauty he saw.
That is what Hashem sees when He looks at us.
• • •
When Hashem sees a person carrying anxiety and imperfection, struggling to daven, struggling to maintain shalom bayis, struggling to pass their heritage to children who do not always want to receive it, and that person still tries, still lights Shabbos candles, still sits at a Seder, still reaches toward something higher, Hashem turns to the angels and says: did you ever see anything more beautiful?
This is precisely how Parshas Pekudei concludes. After all the human work, after the beams are raised and the curtains are hung, the Torah tells us that vayechas he’anan et Ohel Moed, u’kavod Hashem malei et haMishkan (Shemot 40:34). The cloud covered the Tent of Meeting, and the glory of Hashem filled the Mishkan.
Not the Mishkan of the perfect blueprint. The Mishkan that Betzalel built, assembled by human hands in the desert, imperfect and finite and holy.
Today we have no Temple. We have no altar. Our Mishkan is our homes. Our avodah is the life we are actually living, not the one we once imagined we would have.
Do not mourn the life you did not have. The life you have, with all of its struggles and imperfections, is the Mishkan Hashem chose.
Build it.
He will come.
Rabbi Benny Berlin is spiritual leader of BACH in Long Beach, www.bachlongbeach.com.
Write: Columnist@TheJewishStar.com
