Books

‘Corrupt Comparison’ Knocks Out the apartheid smear

Posted

South African legal and political scholar Anthea Jeffery told a forum in Jerusalem last week that “there must be a huge fightback against the propaganda” that falsely labels Israel an apartheid state.

In her latest book, “Corrupt Comparison: South Africa, Israel, and the Hijacking of History,” Jeffery draws on decades of research to compare South Africa’s apartheid laws with Israeli policies on both sides of the Green Line.

The book argues that the two systems have little in common and traces the accusation to Soviet Cold War disinformation campaigns and its later promotion through activist reports, United Nations resolutions and international legal proceedings.

Jeffery warned that propaganda and the use of international law as a political weapon were making a fair resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict increasingly difficult. She recalled how Soviet intelligence officials sought to sway Western public opinion by repeating misleading narratives until they became widely accepted.

Her argument extends beyond Israel. The book contends that the apartheid accusation is part of a broader campaign targeting the United States and other Western democracies.

“The apartheid accusation against Israel is part of a multidimensional war against the West, which has been steadily intensifying for decades,” she writes in the preface. “Many elements in that war have already been identified, making it easier to counter them. The apartheid element is less readily apparent and thus too little understood.

“This book seeks to remedy that situation. It aims to help those wanting to safeguard Western democracy to recognize what is at stake in this additional arena of the conflict.” 

Jeffery, a longtime researcher at the South African Institute of Race Relations, discussed “Corrupt Comparison,” her 13th book, at a Nov. 10 event at the Friends of Zion Museum with Benji Shulman, director of the Johannesburg-based Middle East Africa Research Institute.

Their discussion followed South Africa’s Nov. 4 municipal elections, in which the ruling African National Congress (ANC) received 30.76% of the national vote, down from 45.59% in the 2021 local elections. The two experts said the results could open the door to a change in South Africa’s hostile posture toward Israel.

The Democratic Alliance (DA), the ANC’s principal rival and its partner in the national unity government, won 24.64%, while former President Jacob Zuma’s uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) party received 9.76%. The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), led by Julius Malema, took 6.22%.

The results marked another steep decline for the ANC, which has governed South Africa since the end of apartheid in 1994. “The ANC is now a 30% party,” Shulman said.

If the ANC-DA unity government survives, the ANC’s continued decline could open the way to a different approach to Israel, he said, pointing to the 2029 national elections as a possible turning point.

For years, the ANC successfully stigmatized its opponents, particularly the DA, by portraying them as representatives of white interests who might seek to restore apartheid, Jeffery said.

But those accusations were losing their force as voters increasingly judged parties on performance, she argued.

Jeffery pointed to failing electricity supplies, water infrastructure, roads, traffic lights and garbage collection in many ANC-controlled municipalities.

“If you’re in an ANC area, things don’t work,” she said.

By contrast, she said, the DA had shown it could provide better services, including in predominantly Black communities.

Shulman said the DA faced a delicate calculation on Israel. Although the party has traditionally been more moderate than the ANC on foreign policy, it is seeking to broaden its appeal, including among South Africa’s Muslim communities.

He recalled that the ANC had made Palestinian solidarity a central theme of its 2024 national election campaign, including at a major rally in Cape Town, a DA stronghold, where Palestinian flags dominated.

“Palestine was a core part of the ANC’s electoral campaign,” Shulman said.

The strategy, he argued, failed to deliver the gains the ANC sought.

The DA, meanwhile, has generally preferred to focus on domestic governance and service delivery rather than become embroiled in disputes over Israel, he said, while smaller parties, including the African Christian Democratic Party, the Inkatha Freedom Party and the Patriotic Alliance, have taken more outspoken positions.

Shulman suggested that a shifting balance of power could eventually allow South Africa to reconsider its confrontational relationship with Israel, although a shakeup could also push the ANC toward parties even more hostile to Israel, such as the EFF and MK.