antisemitism symposium

FIGHT BACK! Touro University confronts antisemitism

‘We are proud Jews, we are strong Jews, Jews without trembling knees.’

Posted

Speakers at Touro University’s Symposium on Antisemitism on Monday, Nov. 16, were blunt in their assessment of out-of-control Jew-hatred — but also hopeful that through considered action truth can prevail.

•Touro President Dr. Alan Kadish warned that America might be headed toward the Germany of the 1930s.

•David Harris, former longtime CEO of the American Jewish Commit-tee, said US Jews are fighting a war without a plan, and are losing. But he predicted that American Jews will not cower.

•Touro law professor Thane Rosenbaum said that those who claim to oppose only Israel really prefer a world where Jews had nowhere to go. But he cited the expanded use of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act to protect Jews and the acceptance of the IHRA definition of anti-semitism as hopeful signs.

•Zionist Organization of America National President Mort Klein said that “big lies” that have been used against Jews for centuries have returned in new forms. “We have to fight back against these lies,” he said.

The four-and-a-half hour event took place in Touro's Cross River Campus at 3 Times Square.

Klein traced the history of Jew-hate from medieval allegations of poisoned wells to various blood libels to the Nazi claim that Jews caused Germany’s defeat in World War I. Today’s lies are genocide, famine, colonialism, occupation and apartheid, he said.

“This gigantic, dangerous lie of genocide — my G-d, there are more Gaza Arabs now living in Gaza than there were when October 7th happened. This is a hell of a genocide,” Klein said.

Klein saved his harshest words for Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, calling him “a monster killer: and saying it angers him when Israeli officials merely discount Abbas as not a partner for peace.

“Would you say about Hitler, ‘He’s not a partner for peace’?” Klein asked. “He’s a monster killer.”

The ZOA chief cited PA payments to terrorists and their families.

His call to action: write to Congress, write letters and op-eds, attend and run for school boards, and pressure rabbis and Jewish organi-zations to speak out. He also urged support for Jewish day schools, camps and synagogue attendance.

Harris, now executive vice president of the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP), said it was time for Jews to reconsider their response to the tsunami of antisemitism and fight back.

“We are proud Jews, we are strong Jews, and we are Jews without trembling knees,” he said.

“We need to reassess our advocacy organizations — some have still not gotten the memo,” he said, adding that Jews should also review their approach to allyship. “We cannot spend all our time chasing af-ter old putative allies; some were there after October 7, some were not.”

He urged Jews to stop being frayers (suckers) and become “smart, savvy consumers and philanthropists.”

Rosenbaum, whose Jewish Journal column appears frequently in The Jewish Star, said it is “preposterous” not to see anti-Zionism and antisemitism as conjoined twins.

“You can’t have one without the other,” he said.

He took aim at the familiar line, “I’m against Israel. That doesn’t mean I’m against Jews.” What that person really means, Rosenbaum argued, is a preference for the 2,000 years when Jews endured ex-iles, expulsions, pogroms and forced conversions, with no safe ha-ven.

“I have nothing against Jews,” he said, mimicking the argument. “I just don’t want them to have any place to go.”

Such critics, he said, are content with 22 Arab states that have “no human rights, no gay rights, no women’s rights, no rule of law, no freedom of speech,” yet judge the lone Jewish democracy so harshly that they would strip it of self-determination.

They also presume to tell Jews who they are, something no one would tell any other ethnic or national group, he said.

He praised Kenneth Marcus, who spoke earlier, for using Title VI of the Civil Rights Act in a way it had never been used before — to protect Jews as a people of shared ancestry, not only a religion — so that discrimination against Zionists can cost a school its federal funding.

“The vast majority of Jews, I think it’s over 80%, identified them-selves as Zionists,” Rosenbaum said. So “if you’re discriminating against me because I’m a Zionist, you’re an antisemite.”

Marcus is the founder, chairman and CEO of the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law.

Rosenbaum championed the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition of antisemitism, adopted by dozens of countries, hundreds of universities and the US State Department, noting that it bars applying a double standard to Israel, holding Jews collectively responsible for Israel’s actions, and comparing Israelis to Nazis.

“If you’re not interested” in the occupations of Northern Cyprus, Kashmir and Kurdistan, “you’re a Jew hater because you only seem to be interested in one occupation.”

Rosenbaum ridiculed the “context dependent” answer three univer-sity presidents gave Congress in 2023 when asked whether calling for the genocide of Jews violated their schools’ codes of conduct.

No campus, he said, would accept “context” or the First Amendment as a defense for a student who chose to express opposition to racial preferences by chanting “Lynch Blacks.”

The same twisted logic shields “globalize the intifada,” a slogan Mayor Zohran Mamdani has suggested does not mean what critics think, Rosenbaum said. “It means actually one thing: kill Jews wher-ever you find them globally,” Rosenbaum said.

The argument, he said, boils down to: “The First Amendment pro-tects my right to hate Jews, as long as I frame it in anti-Zionist terms.”

Touro’s Kadish closed with his own warning.

“America in 2026 is not Germany in 1938,” he said. “But if we’re not careful, America in 2027 may be Germany in 1931. That means we’ve got a lot of work to do.”

Noting that antisemitism drives the largest share of hate incidents in New York, he said it must be fought “to protect our society, not just to protect ourselves.”

He rejected despair, recalling a teacher who told him that “pessi-mism is not a Jewish trait.”

He said efforts discussed during the symposium, from education to “taking back the campus,” can make a difference.

“But it will require concerted effort,” Kadish said. “It will require working together, and it will require a recognition that the problem is real. The problem is imminent, and the problem can be disastrous if we don’t address it.”

Those who spoke at the Touro symposium also included Dr. Charles Asher Small, founding executive director and president of ISGAP; Cameron “Cam” Fink, co-founder and CEO of AARU Market Re-search; Dr. Larisa Buhin-Krenek, professor and dean, undergraduate program, Touro University Berlin; Dr. Peter Klein, dean, MA in Holocaust Studies, Touro University Berlin; Dr. Oren Stier, director and professor, Holocaust and Genocide Studies Program at Florida International University; Daniel Rosenberg, founding partner of Pi-ro; Anne Bayefsky, director of the Touro Institute on Human Rights and the Holocaust; Richard Behar, contributing editor and investigattive journalist at Forbes; and Dr. Andrew Pessin, professor of philosophy at Connecticut College.